01 · The mechanism
Altitude is an input, not a refinement
Under BS EN 1991-1-3 and its UK National Annex, the characteristic ground snow load at a site is derived from that site’s own location, and it increases with altitude. This is not a marginal correction applied at the end of a calculation. It is one of the inputs the calculation begins from.
Where this bites hardest in BritainConurbations built against high ground, where altitude changes sharply inside a single travel-to-work area: Greater Manchester toward the Saddleworth moors, Sheffield toward the Peak District, West Yorkshire on the Pennine flank, the South Wales valleys, and much of Scotland. In flat country the effect is a rounding error. In these places it is not.
The error has a direction
A site on higher ground assessed using a value drawn from lower ground receives a load that is too small. The reverse case — a low site assessed on a high value — produces a conservative answer that fails safe. The asymmetry matters: this class of error errs towards optimism, never towards caution, and an optimistic structural answer is the one that does not get discovered until something happens.
And it is invisible in the output
A report produced from a centroid looks identical to one produced from the site. The figure is present, the standard is cited, the conclusion is stated. Nothing on the face of the document reveals which value was used or where it came from.